Take, for example, the standard elementary school lesson about how Christopher Columbus discovered America in 1492. What are we really teaching our children?
Let's unpack this:
Did Christopher Columbus Discover the Americas, Period?
No. Humans have lived in the Americas for at least 20,000 years. By the time Columbus arrived, the Americas were populated by hundreds of small nations and several regional empires.
Was Christopher Columbus the First European to Locate the Americas by Sea?
No. Leif Erikson already did that about 500 years before Columbus set sail, and he may not have been the first.
Was Christopher Columbus the First European to Create a Settlement in the Americas?
No. Archaeologists have discovered a Norse settlement in eastern Canada, most likely created by Erikson, that dates back to the early 11th century. There is also a credible, albeit controversial, theory suggesting that European migration to the Americas may predate recorded human history.
Why Didn't the Norse Create More Settlements?
Because it wasn't practical to do so. The journey was long, dangerous, and difficult to navigate.
So What Did Christopher Columbus Do, Exactly?
He became the first European in recorded history to successfully conquer a small part of the Americas, then establish a trade route for the transportation of slaves and goods. In other words, Christopher Columbus didn't discover America; he monetized it. As he boasted to the Spanish royal finance minister, upon completion of his first voyage:
[T]heir highnesses can see that I will give them as much gold as they may need, if their highness will render me very slight assistance; moreover, I will give them spices and cotton, as much as their highnesses shall command; and mastic, as much as they shall order to be shipped and which, up to now, has been found only in Greece, in the island of Chios, and the Seignory sells it for what it pleases; and aloe, as much as they shall order to be shipped; and slaves, as many as they shall order to be shipped and who will be from the idolaters. I believe also that I have found rhubarb and cinnamon, and I shall find a thousand other things of value...The voyage of 1492 was still a dangerous passage into uncharted territories, but Christopher Columbus was neither the first European to visit the Americas nor the first to establish a settlement there. His motives were anything but honorable, and his behavior was purely self-serving. He was, in effect, an ambitious pirate with a Spanish royal charter.
Why Does This Matter?
From a civil liberties point of view, the claim that Christopher Columbus discovered America contains several problematic implications. The most serious is the idea that the Americas were in any sense undiscovered when they were, in fact, already occupied. This belief - which would later be more explicitly incorporated into the idea of Manifest Destiny - obscures the horrifying moral implications of what Columbus, and those who followed him, did.
There are also troubling, albeit more abstract, First Amendment implications to our government's decision to enforce a national mythology by having our educational system tell children a lie in the name of patriotism, then require them to regurgitate this "correct" answer on tests in order to pass.
Our government expends considerable funds to defend this lie every year on Columbus Day, which is understandably upsetting for many survivors of the American Indian genocide and their allies. As Suzanne Benally, the executive director of Cultural Survival, puts it:
We ask that on this Columbus Day, a reflection of historical facts be observed. By the time European colonizers arrived, Indigenous people had already been on this continent for more than 20,000 years. We were farmers, scientists, astronomers, artists, mathematicians, singers, architects, physicians, teachers, mother, fathers, and Elders living in sophisticated societies …Christopher Columbus did not discover America, and there is no good reason to keep pretending that he did.
We object to a false and hurtful holiday that perpetuates a vision of a land open to conquest of its Native inhabitants, their highly evolved societies, and natural resources. We stand in solidarity with the call to transform Columbus Day by not recognizing and honoring the day as Columbus Day.